T4

Crypto vs Cash Savings Calculator

Compare what could happen across different savings strategies. Educational estimates only — past performance does not predict future results.

Configure Your Comparison

$
$
1 yr5 yrs10 yrs

These are hypothetical scenarios, not predictions

Past performance does not predict future results. Crypto markets are fundamentally unpredictable. These ranges are based on historical data and actual outcomes could be far outside these ranges, including total loss.

High-Yield Savings Account

Low Risk

Online savings account offering competitive interest rates. FDIC insured up to $250,000.

Projected Value (5yr)

$7,966

Total Contributed$7,000
Median Gain+$966

No price volatility, but the APY can change as rates adjust.

Worst drawdown feel

None on principal — your deposit is protected. APY may decrease.

Emotional risk

Very low. The only surprise is a rate change notification email.

Bitcoin DCA

High Risk

Dollar-cost averaging into Bitcoin with regular purchases. No insurance. Extremely volatile.

Hypothetical Range (5yr)

Low$219
Median$25,991
High$683,594
Total Contributed$7,000
Median Gain+$18,991

Bitcoin can swing 20-40% in a single month. Multi-year drawdowns have occurred.

Worst drawdown feel

Bitcoin dropped ~77% from its 2021 peak to 2022 lows. Some investors waited over two years to recover.

Emotional risk

Very high. Watching half your savings vanish on screen is psychologically brutal, even if it later recovers.

What this calculator helps with

  • •Understanding the range of possible outcomes for different strategies
  • •Seeing how volatility affects crypto compared to traditional savings
  • •Comparing how much you would contribute versus potential outcomes
  • •Appreciating the emotional and practical risks of each approach
  • •Starting a conversation with a financial advisor using concrete scenarios

What this calculator does NOT predict

  • •Future crypto prices or returns — nobody can predict these
  • •Whether any particular strategy is right for your situation
  • •Tax implications, which vary by jurisdiction and personal circumstances
  • •Black swan events, regulatory changes, or exchange failures
  • •The emotional impact of watching volatile investments in real time
  • •Inflation-adjusted purchasing power of your savings

Why crypto behaves differently than cash savings

Cash savings in an FDIC-insured account have a predictable, stable return. Your principal is protected up to $250,000, and interest accrues steadily. The main risk is inflation eroding purchasing power.

Crypto assets like Bitcoin and Ethereum have no guaranteed return. They can gain or lose 50% or more in a single year. Historical performance shows both dramatic gains and devastating losses. There is no insurance, no guaranteed recovery, and no central authority to make you whole if things go wrong.

This does not make crypto "bad" or savings "good" — they are fundamentally different financial instruments with different risk profiles. Understanding this difference is essential before making any decisions.

The best strategy for you depends on your financial situation, goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon. Consider consulting a qualified financial advisor.

Limitations

  • •Uses simplified historical return ranges, not actual backtested DCA data
  • •Does not account for exchange fees, gas costs, or spread
  • •Does not model tax implications on gains, interest, or yield income
  • •Crypto return ranges are based on past data and may not reflect future performance
  • •HYSA rate (4.5% APY) is a current snapshot and will change over time
  • •Does not model inflation or purchasing power changes
  • •Split strategy uses a simplified blended return, not actual rebalancing math
  • •Stablecoin yield ranges assume no protocol failure or depeg event

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this calculator predicting what my money will be worth?+
No. This calculator shows hypothetical scenarios based on historical ranges. Past performance does not predict future results. Crypto markets are fundamentally unpredictable, and future returns could be far outside historical ranges. Use this only as an educational comparison tool.
Why does the calculator show a range instead of a single number?+
Because crypto returns are highly variable. Showing a single number would falsely imply precision. The range (low / median / high) reflects the wide spread of historical outcomes. Even these ranges may not capture future extremes.
Is a high-yield savings account really risk-free?+
FDIC-insured savings accounts protect your principal up to $250,000, so the deposited amount is very safe. However, the interest rate can change, and inflation may erode your purchasing power over time. The 'risk' is more about opportunity cost and purchasing power, not losing your deposit.
What is dollar-cost averaging (DCA)?+
Dollar-cost averaging means investing a fixed amount at regular intervals (e.g., $100 per month) regardless of price. This strategy avoids the risk of investing a lump sum at a market peak, but it also means you may buy at various prices. DCA does not guarantee profits or protect against losses.
Should I move my savings into crypto based on these numbers?+
This tool does not make recommendations. It shows hypothetical scenarios for education. Any decision to invest in crypto should be based on your personal financial situation, risk tolerance, and ideally guidance from a qualified financial advisor. Never invest more than you can afford to lose.
Why are stablecoin yields risky if the coin is stable?+
The stablecoin price stays near $1, but the yield comes from lending or DeFi protocols that carry smart contract risk, platform insolvency risk, and potential stablecoin depeg risk. Past collapses (UST, Celsius, Voyager) showed that 'stable' yields can vanish overnight with total loss of principal. There is no FDIC insurance.

Related tools

1

Tax Impact Preview

Understand tax implications before you act

2

Exchange Recommender

Find the right exchange for buying crypto

3

Stablecoin Selector

Compare stablecoins if considering yield strategies

4

Cost Optimizer

Find the cheapest way to accomplish your crypto goal

Learn more

Guide: Crypto taxes explained Guide: Understanding gas fees Security checklist for crypto

This tool provides educational information only. It is not financial, tax, or legal advice. Always consult qualified professionals for decisions about your specific situation. Results are based on general patterns and may not reflect your circumstances.